Sunday, March 8, 2015

AR15 Compensators - Do They Really Reduce Recoil ?



This is an experiment I've been wanting to do for a long time. So having a Monday off for MLK Day, I headed to the ranch with no kids to distract me.

I was curious about the effects of a compensator or muzzle brake if you could eliminate the human factor. So I strapped my rifle to a work bench stand and used the Hands Off Trigger Release to actuate the trigger. Capturing the results of each muzzle brake with the video camera, I was able to see the linear effectiveness of each brake.

My conclusion is fairly obvious... any compensator is better than nothing at all. However, every muzzle brake I tested but one (the Dragon's Head from Surplus Ammo) performed the same as far as the X & Y movement of the rifle is concerned. This result was most unexpected. I was expecting to see much more of a difference between the muzzle brakes. I suspect with all the various models on the market and all linear movement being equal, there has to be a difference in how they perform on the Z axis. I have a few ideas how to test for this so I may give that a try.









m16 ar15 rifle carbine muzzle flash hider comp compensator brake military A1 A2
A1 Flash Hider
m16 ar15 rifle carbine muzzlelinear comp compensator brake military surplus ammo
Surplus Ammo & Arms (SAA) "Dragon's Head"
m16 ar15 rifle carbine muzzle flash enhancer comp compensator brake military
Double Star "Flash Enhancer"
m16 ar15 rifle carbine muzzleJP Enterprises tactical comp compensator brake military
JP Enterprises
m16 ar15 rifle carbine muzzle Lantac Dragon 556 comp compensator brake military
Lantac "Dragon Advanced Muzzle Brake"
m16 ar15 rifle carbine muzzle Surefire flash hider comp compensator brake military
SureFire
m16 ar15 rifle carbine muzzle flash hider comp compensator brake military AAC Advanced Armament blackout
Advanced Armament Corporation (AAC) "Blackout 51T"
m16 ar15 rifle carbine muzzle Bnaks Bullets comp compensator brake military
Banks Bullets
m16 ar15 rifle carbine muzzle flash hider comp compensator brake military AAC Advanced Amrament 51t breakout
Advanced Armament Corporation (AAC) "Breakout 51T"